Geologist Says He Found Lost Tomb of Jesus;
If True, Christianity Is a Lie
Geologist Dr. Aryeh Shimron claims to have found the "lost tomb of Jesus" in Jerusalem, proclaimed the Drudge Report (9/18/16). This is known as the Talpiot Tomb, first discovered in 1980.
The implications of
this claim, if it were true, are enormous — world-changing.
Writing for The
Sun (UK), Hannah Farrett notes, "he apparently has proof that
Jesus Christ is buried at a site in East Jerusalem. But now Aryeh has done some
tests, which he says prove Jesus of Nazareth, his wife Mary Magdalene and SON
Judah were laid to rest there."
She adds, "There
are nine burial boxes in the tomb, and they all have names with links to the
New Testament of the Bible on them …. This was highly controversial, given
Christians believe Jesus was resurrected …. Some people rubbished the claims,
saying all the names etched on the boxes were so common at the time there's no
way of drawing any conclusions."
It certainly is
"highly controversial." But is it true?
Short answer: No.
Dr. Paul L. Maier,
Harvard-trained retired professor of ancient history at Western Michigan University,
is a best-selling author. Most of his books are non-fiction. But he once wrote
a novel called, A Skeleton in God's Closet.
The book deals with an
alleged discovery of Jesus' tomb — providing actual "proof" that
Jesus had not risen from the dead — bodily, historically, physically — and that
the whole Christian church in all of its manifestations was, therefore, built
on a lie. Soon, the whole thing (Christianity) collapsed — as well it should —
if Jesus has not indeed risen from the dead.
For this column, I
reached out to some leading New Testament scholars for comments.
Dr. Maier emailed me:
"It seems that sensationalizing writers about Jesus always try twice to
gain public attention with their bizarre claims when their first effort fails
.... Now Israeli Geologist Aryeh Shimron has done the same thing in the case of
the Talpiot Tomb in Jerusalem. Virtually the same headlines were used now as
when the 'discovery' was first announced in 2007. It was junk then, it is junk
now. The current warmed-over version will receive the same reception now as
nine years ago: Dead on Arrival."
Dr. Michael Licona
teaches at Houston Baptist University. The conclusion of his 700-plus page
book, The Resurrection of Jesus: A New Historiographical Approach, states:
"Jesus' resurrection from the dead is the best historical explanation of
the relevant historical bedrock" (p. 610).
He adds, "Since
it fulfills all five of the criteria for the best explanation and outdistances
competing hypotheses by a significant margin in their ability to fulfill the
same criteria, the historian is warranted in regarding Jesus' resurrection as
an event that occurred in the past."
Responding to this new
story, Licona wrote me: "Some things in history are more certain than
others. One fact that is virtually certain is Jesus' disciples were convinced
their rabbi had risen from the dead and had appeared to them. The data
supporting this fact are so secure that virtually 100 percent of all historians
of Jesus grant it, whether Jewish, agnostic, or atheist."
And Licona notes,
"Moreover, the earliest Christians proclaimed that Jesus had been raised
bodily, leaving behind an empty grave. Dr. Shimron must explain how Jesus's
corpse went missing, then received an honorable burial without any of His
disciples ever learning about it. It seems more likely that Dr. Shimron is
engaged in wishful thinking and that his claim to have found the family tomb of
Jesus will soon be laid to rest in the graveyard of discarded fanciful
hypotheses."
Dr. Gary Habermas of
Liberty University is a walking encyclopedia on the resurrection of Jesus and
has written on it voluminously. His book, The Secret of the Talpiot
Tomb: Unraveling the Mystery of the Jesus Family Tomb (2008), shows
why the Talpiot Tomb could not possibly contain the tomb of Jesus of Nazareth.
Habermas emailed me,
"Thankfully, virtually no scholars support him [Shimron] at all."
Finally, I also
received feedback on the alleged "lost tomb of Jesus" from Dr.
Darrell Bock, one of the world's leading New Testament scholars. Bock teaches
at Dallas Theological Seminary.
He emailed me,
"Nothing has changed since this erroneous
conclusion was originally proposed. Jesus would not be
in a family tomb as his execution as a felon prevented
him by Jewish tradition from being buried in a
family tomb. In the Mishnah, Sanhedrin 6.5 says, 'And
they did not bury [the felon] in the burial grounds of his
ancestors.' So no burial with the family."
conclusion was originally proposed. Jesus would not be
in a family tomb as his execution as a felon prevented
him by Jewish tradition from being buried in a
family tomb. In the Mishnah, Sanhedrin 6.5 says, 'And
they did not bury [the felon] in the burial grounds of his
ancestors.' So no burial with the family."
In short, the claim
that the lost tomb of Jesus has been found is just recycled sensationalist
rubble. As Maier noted: "I guess there is no end to the way these deluded
sensationalists will try to whack a dead horse!"
In short, Jesus is
risen indeed.